M·E·L Research Delivers 30 Year Impact Evaluation for Kick It Out
We are thrilled to have worked in collaboration with Kick It Out, to shed light on the journey of inclusivity in football over the past three decades and the role Kick it Out as an organisation has played in that journey. This comprehensive evaluation, integrating quantitative and qualitative methodologies, and introducing an SROI model to one of Kick it Out’s headline programmes – Raise your Game – offers profound insights into the perceptions of football fans, the role of Kick It Out, and the efficacy of the work undertaken over the last three decades.
Our in-depth research examines the evolution of inclusivity within the football landscape since 1993. By engaging with 2,503 football fans, including 28 participants via a week-long online community, the study captures diverse perspectives and experiences across generations. Within the quantitative sample 1,500 fans were aged 45 or older, to ensure a large enough sample of participants who could remember a time before Kick it Out. The project’s multifaceted approach also included a comprehensive review of historical data and literature.
Bronwyn Vermaat, who was the day to day project lead for M·E·L Research, said:
“This research resonates deeply with my own and M·E·L Research’s values, by providing crucial insights into the struggle against discrimination. The opportunity to speak to fans themselves, particularly those from minority or less represented backgrounds, about the changes they have witnessed, and the ways in which Kick It Out’s initiatives have catalysed positive change within football by influencing attitudes, policies, and behaviours on and off the field, was both heartening and enlightening. While encouraging to see the large strides that have been made in the past 30 years, the research served as a reminder of the barriers that many still face. However, it also served as a demonstration that the work of dedicated organisations like Kick It Out can lead to tangible progress in dismantling barriers and fostering an environment where diversity truly thrives.”
Key Findings and Implications
The study found that Kick It Out’s efforts have significantly contributed to reducing discrimination. The majority of fans say there is less discrimination in football now than 30 years ago or when they first became a football fan and 73% of fans believe football has become more inclusive.
Sixty seven percent (67%) of those who experienced discrimination, say that they experience it less often now, due to the work of Kick it Out. 79% of those who’ve heard of the anti-discrimination organisation stated it has contributed to a more inclusive game.
Kick it Out has become a leading voice in the fight against discrimination in football, with 68% of fans recognising it as an organisation or group involved in this fight.
Seventy-four percent (74%) of fans state that their peers are more concerned about discrimination now than 30 years ago or when they first became football fans. Among fans who have heard of Kick it Out, 92% say this change is at least in part due to Kick it Out.
Seventy percent (70%) of those surveyed believe they would probably or definitely call out a friend if they witnessed them engaging in discriminatory behaviour, although only 34% believe they would call out a stranger.
Forty three percent (43%) of fans state that they are more likely to call out discrimination now than they were when Kick it Out was founded or when they first became a fan, with 73% of those who have heard of Kick it Out saying that they contributed to this change.
Thirty-one percent (31%) of those asked have experienced discriminatory behaviour towards either themselves or others online, and 76% are concerned online abuse is impacting on football’s inclusivity.
However, while the data highlights the significant strides that have been taken over the past 30 years, Kick It Out believes that its work remains more relevant than ever, with chair Sanjay Bhandari stating: “Now is not the time for football to rest on its laurels.”
“As this report demonstrates, Kick It Out has changed the face of football for the better since its inception 30 years ago. Fans from minority groups believe football is now safer, more inclusive and more welcoming, because of Kick It Out’s work. We also know from this report that Kick It Out has given people more confidence to call out or report discrimination, and we have seen evidence of this firsthand through our own annual reporting statistics.
“As we reach this historic milestone it gives us a moment to stop and reflect on the journey that we have been on, but we know that there is still much work to be done and this research only serves to highlight that fans overwhelmingly want more action to tackle discrimination throughout the game.”
Sanjay Bhandari, Chair, Kick It Out
In closing, Elliot Simmonds, who oversaw the project for M·E·L Research said:
“There is clearly still some work to be done – particularly in digital spaces – before we are in a footballing and sporting world where the need for organisations like Kick it Out disappears. However, the findings from this report are positive and show the progress that has been made over the last three decades. I would like to specifically thank the team at Kick it Out and the wider M·E·L team, many of whom contributed to this study. Most importantly, however, we must thank the fans and participants who gave their time and provided such candid feedback as part of the survey and of course within the online community and in-depth SROI discussions.”
Last week, I had the opportunity to speak at Collections Inside & Out, a symposium hosted at National Trust Chirk Castle & Garden, bringing together people working across gardens, horticulture, heritage, collections and interpretation.
I was, perhaps, a slight interloper among so many people with deep horticultural expertise but every presentation was incredibly interesting and I learned a lot – and broadly managed to follow the general flow of what was being said (still not 100% au fait with taxa…
We’re pleased to share that our Commercial Director, Elliot Simmonds, will be speaking at the Collections Inside & Out symposium at National Trust Chirk Castle & Garden on 24 September 2026. Bringing together professionals working across heritage collections, gardens and landscapes, the symposium will explore the relationship between indoor and outdoor heritage and the opportunities created by thinking about them as part of a connected visitor experience.
Elliot’s session, “Integrating Indoor…
M·E·L Research has been named the winner of the Award for Outstanding Contribution to Social Value & Ethical Research 2026 at the UK Enterprise Awards.
The award recognises the values that shape both the work we choose to undertake and the way we deliver it. From building trauma-informed practices into our research to improving inclusion and reinvesting in the communities around us, social responsibility is part of how we operate every day.
M·E·L Research joined the British Dyslexia Association (BDA) at the House of Lords this week for the launch of a new report exploring the experiences of dyslexic young people who are not in employment, education or training (NEET).
Tamsin Maries, Senior Research Manager, and Elliot Simmonds, Commercial Manager, represented M·E·L Research at the event…
New UK-wide research from M·E·L Research’s SPARK report shows improving mental health indicators alongside continuing exposure to suicide, widespread lifetime suicidal thoughts and significant gaps in practical knowledge.
Suicide prevention depends on understanding not only how many people are affected, but also how confident the public feel about recognising risk, starting difficult conversations and finding appropriate support. The Spring 2026 SPARK report from M·E·L Research brings these issues together, providing a detailed picture of attitudes…
M·E·L Research is pleased to be supporting the Diocese of Manchester with an independent consultation to help inform its future leadership. The research will provide opportunities for people connected with diocesan life, as well as members of the wider community, to share their perspectives on the local context, priorities for the years ahead and the qualities that will be important in future leadership.
Across Europe, we have seen devastating wildfires destroy homes, habitats and communities. They offer us a powerful analogy for how we think about suicide prevention.
When a fire is raging, everything must be done to put it out. Firefighters, emergency services and communities mobilise to save lives. But even when the fire is eventually extinguished, enormous damage may already have been done, and recovery can take years. That is why fire services don’t only fight fires. They also invest in prevention: identifying risks, educating people, installing smoke alarms, creating fire breaks and trying to stop…
My son Jools was 14 years old when he died suddenly in April 2022. There was no note. There was no offline evidence that explained why he died. No one had seen or been aware of any adverse mental health issues, and at his original inquest the coroner could not be sure that Jools was in a suicidal mood. More than four years later, I am still trying to understand what happened to my son. Yet one enormous part of Jools’ life was not properly explored following his death: his digital world. Like almost every teenager, Jools had a life on his phone. Social…
