Cumberland Council: Residents’ Survey
Background & Context
The client was Cumberland Council, a newly formed local authority created by bringing together services from multiple former district and county councils. As a new organisation, the Council did not have any existing residents survey data and therefore lacked a baseline to understand resident perceptions, satisfaction, and priorities.
The core business need was to generate robust, representative insight into residents’ views to inform decision making, service improvement, and future performance tracking. The Council also wanted to benchmark findings against national data from the Local Government Association to understand how local perceptions compared more widely.
The research sought to understand residents’ experiences of living in the area, their satisfaction with Council services, perceptions of value for money, and the extent to which they felt informed, listened to, and able to influence decisions. It also aimed to identify variation across different population groups and geographic areas, including three defined localities within Cumberland.
A key challenge was ensuring inclusive participation across a large and diverse geography, including residents with differing levels of digital access and confidence. The topic itself included potentially sensitive areas such as financial hardship, perceptions of safety, and trust in public services. Reaching a representative sample, including those who may be less engaged or harder to reach, was therefore critical to the success of the project.
Approach
A quantitative residents survey was designed and delivered using a mixed mode methodology, combining postal self completion with an online completion option. This approach ensured accessibility for residents with low digital confidence while still offering convenience for those preferring digital channels.
A stratified random sampling approach was used to select households across all wards in Cumberland. Addresses were ranked using Index of Multiple Deprivation data to ensure representation from communities with varying levels of need and deprivation.
A total of 6,000 households were selected and mailed a survey pack. Each pack included a paper questionnaire, covering letter, and details for completing the survey online via a link or QR code. A reminder mailing was issued to non responders to boost participation.
The survey was open to any household member aged 18 or over. Materials were written in plain English and supported by a helpline to assist respondents where needed, helping to reduce barriers to participation.
In total, 1,228 completed surveys were achieved, exceeding the target sample size and enabling robust analysis at both overall Council level and across the three locality areas of North, Mid and South Cumberland.
The achieved sample was then weighted by age, gender, ethnicity, and location to ensure it accurately reflected the resident population. The final dataset achieved a high level of statistical reliability, with a confidence level of approximately ±3 percent at the overall level.
Outputs
Analysis combined descriptive statistical analysis with subgroup comparisons, identifying statistically significant differences across demographic and geographic groups. Weighting was applied prior to analysis to ensure representativeness. Confidence intervals were calculated to support robust interpretation of findings.
The project also included:
- Spatial analysis, grouping wards into three locality areas to enable more robust geographic comparisons
- Benchmarking analysis against national Local Government Association data to provide wider context
- Sub group analysis highlighting differences by age, financial situation, digital access, and other key characteristics
Outputs provided to the client included:
- A full dataset in Excel format
- Cross tabulated data tables for detailed analysis
- A comprehensive written report presenting findings, insights, and interpretation
Findings were designed to directly inform service planning, communications strategy, and prioritisation of improvements. The results established a baseline for future tracking, enabling the Council to measure change over time and assess the impact of interventions.
Latest News
Industry Insights
Beyond visitor numbers: Rethinking how we measure the value of culture and heritage
November 2026
How do we demonstrate the true value of culture and heritage? And are we measuring everything that matters?
These were two of the questions that stood out during the third day of the Culture and Heritage Capital: Putting Theory into Practice conference.
Cultural organisations have long recognised that their impact extends beyond visitor numbers, ticket sales and tourism revenue. Museums, heritage sites and cultural programmes can support mental health and wellbeing, strengthen community connections, create opportunities for learning and preserve our shared…
Read the full post
M·E·L News
M·E·L Research appointed to evaluate the BFI Film Academy programme
October 2026
M·E·L Research is pleased to be working with the British Film Institute (BFI) on a three-year evaluation of the BFI Film Academy programme. Since 2012, BFI Film Academy has supported young people to develop skills, confidence, knowledge and networks and explore routes into careers across the screen industries. The refreshed 2026–2029 programme builds on this experience, creating connected pathways from early engagement through to specialist training, mentoring, placements and industry-facing progression, with a strong emphasis on…
Read the full post
M·E·L News
M·E·L Research welcomes new talent as our teams continue to grow
October 2026
M·E·L Research is pleased to welcome four new colleagues to our growing team, strengthening our research and evaluation expertise as we continue to expand our services and support clients.
The appointments of Laura Karban, Associate Director; Bethan Jewsbury, Senior Evaluation Managers; and Chloe Parker, Research Manager, alongside Rhoslyn Davies, who joins us on a short-term basis to provide additional senior evaluation support, bring a wealth of experience across social research, evaluation, public policy…
Read the full post
Industry Insights
Women’s health social research: We’ve talked about the problems. Now let’s do something about them.
October 2026
It was an absolute honour to attend the Women’s Health Conference in London this week, bringing together clinicians, policymakers, campaigners and others passionate about improving women’s health.
As a researcher specialising in women’s health social research, I was excited to have the opportunity to learn, be challenged and exchange ideas with people who share that passion. And I wasn’t disappointed.
There has (quite rightly) been a lot of discussion recently about the gender health gap. But some of the evidence shared…
Read the full post
M·E·L News
Collections inside and out: thinking differently about gardens, heritage and the visitor experience
September 2026
Last week, I had the opportunity to speak at Collections Inside & Out, a symposium hosted at National Trust Chirk Castle & Garden, bringing together people working across gardens, horticulture, heritage, collections and interpretation.
I was, perhaps, a slight interloper among so many people with deep horticultural expertise but every presentation was incredibly interesting and I learned a lot – and broadly managed to follow the general flow of what was being said (still not 100% au fait with taxa…
Read the full post
M·E·L News
Elliot Simmonds to present at Collections Inside & Out Symposium
September 2026
We’re pleased to share that our Commercial Director, Elliot Simmonds, will be speaking at the Collections Inside & Out symposium at National Trust Chirk Castle & Garden on 24 September 2026. Bringing together professionals working across heritage collections, gardens and landscapes, the symposium will explore the relationship between indoor and outdoor heritage and the opportunities created by thinking about them as part of a connected visitor experience.
Elliot’s session, “Integrating Indoor…
Read the full post
M·E·L News
M·E·L Research recognised for outstanding contribution to social value and ethical research
August 2026
M·E·L Research has been named the winner of the Award for Outstanding Contribution to Social Value & Ethical Research 2026 at the UK Enterprise Awards.
The award recognises the values that shape both the work we choose to undertake and the way we deliver it. From building trauma-informed practices into our research to improving inclusion and reinvesting in the communities around us, social responsibility is part of how we operate every day.
Read the full post
